Top Medical Billing Clearinghouses Compared: Payer Coverage, ERAs and Gaps
How the major medical billing clearinghouses compare on payer coverage, ERA enrollment, real-time transactions and fees, from their own public pages, and the work none of them carries.
Updated November 19, 2026, based on Availity, Claim.MD, Experian Health, Office Ally, Optum, TriZetto Provider Solutions, Waystar, CMS, CAQH, UnitedHealthcare and Sen. Ron Wyden's office as of that date.
The major medical billing clearinghouses are Availity, Claim.MD, Experian Health, Office Ally, Optum (which owns Change Healthcare), TriZetto Provider Solutions and Waystar. All of them carry claims, remittances and eligibility checks. Where they differ is how many payers they reach for each transaction, how payer enrollment works, how much they publish about pricing, and what they do with payers they can't reach electronically.
None of them reaches every payer for every transaction. This comparison uses each one's own public pages and payer lists to show coverage and gaps. For the basics of what a clearinghouse does, start with what a clearinghouse in medical billing handles.
What to compare before you choose
A single payer count hides most of what matters. These questions decide how much work still lands on staff:
- Payer coverage by transaction. A payer can take claims through a clearinghouse and still not return ERAs, real-time eligibility or claim status through it.
- Enrollment. Which payers need enrollment for claims, for ERAs, or both, and who tracks the paperwork.
- ERA routing. Medicare allows one ERA receiver per NPI, so adding or switching clearinghouses means re-enrolling remits.
- Attachments and appeals. Far fewer payers take these electronically than take claims, so check them payer by payer.
- Fees. Per-transaction charges, paper claims, attachments and payers the clearinghouse treats as non-participating.
- Contract terms. Exclusivity and term length decide how fast you can move if the clearinghouse goes down.
How the major clearinghouses compare
Payer counts and prices come from each company's public pages and change often, so check the current version.
Availity
Availity runs a tiered model. Its help center calls Availity Essentials its "free, health-plan sponsored, multi-payer solution." Essentials Plus is a monthly subscription that lets providers "check eligibility and submit claims for many non-sponsoring payers." Essentials Pro is described as an "integrated, all-payer clearinghouse."
- Coverage: the free tier reaches the payers that sponsor it. Others need Plus, Pro or another route. Availity's payer list shows which payers each tier reaches.
- Pricing: no published prices for Plus or Pro.
- Gap to plan for: check the payer list for each transaction you need, not just the payer's name.
Claim.MD
Claim.MD publishes its prices. Its pricing page lists an Unlimited plan at $120 a month with unlimited claims and ERAs and 1,000 eligibility checks, a Small Volume plan at $60 that includes 100 claims, ERAs and eligibility checks a month, and a Basic plan at $30 that charges per transaction.
- Paper fallback: paper and faxed claims or appeals cost $1.00 for the first five pages and $0.20 per extra page. Attachments are $0.60 each.
- Enrollment: Claim.MD's provider setup docs say Quick Enroll is available for ERA and eligibility only, not for 1500 claims, and providers must submit their first claims within 30 days of Quick Enroll activation. The docs also say Claim.MD "cannot track claim submission enrollments in the same way it tracks ERA enrollments," and some enrollments need paperwork outside the system.
Our Claim.MD clearinghouse guide goes into enrollment and paper claims.
Experian Health
Experian Health publishes detailed payer lists as PDFs. Its claims and ERA payer list marks, for each payer ID, whether claims and ERAs are available, whether enrollment is required, and whether the payer accepts secondary claims and attachments electronically.
- ERA coverage: the list dated November 6, 2026, has about 3,200 claim (837) rows and about 1,700 ERA (835) rows. A few notes say ERAs require EFT enrollment.
- Real-time coverage: on its eligibility and claim status payer list, about 950 of its roughly 1,040 payers are marked for eligibility, and about 500 of those aren't marked for claim status in real time or batch.
- Pricing: not published on these lists.
Office Ally
Office Ally's pricing page says its Service Center lets you "Start for Free," with the footnote "Transactional fees may apply." It lists eligibility at $10 a month for the first 100 transactions and $0.10 each after that, and attachments at $0.55 each.
- Payer flags: its payer list marks payer transactions as "Non-participating payer" and "Enrollment required." Some ERA rows need an active ERA Delivery Change Form on file before ERA files can be retrieved.
- Non-par fees: the pricing page doesn't show what non-participating payers cost, so ask Office Ally.
Our Office Ally clearinghouse guide covers non-par payers, ERA enrollment and rejections.
Optum (Change Healthcare)
Optum's EDI network page describes "a secure network of 2,400 payers" and lists the transactions it carries, including 837 claims, 835 remittances, 270/271 eligibility, 276/277 claim status, 278 authorizations and 275 attachments.
- Outage history: the February 2024 cyberattack on Change Healthcare took its transactions offline. Availity's FAQ from the time said "All transaction types processed by Change Healthcare, including claims, remittances, eligibility, claims, and claims status, are impacted."
- Contracts: in a July 2024 letter to UnitedHealth Group, Senate Finance Committee Chair Ron Wyden wrote that "many providers have exclusive claims processing with Change Healthcare" and had not been clearly released to use another clearinghouse.
Our guide to the Optum (Change Healthcare) clearinghouse covers its payer lists, ERA enrollment and what still needs a portal.
TriZetto Provider Solutions
TriZetto Provider Solutions, part of Cognizant, publishes enrollment averages in its March 2024 clearinghouse enrollment fact sheet. It claims a connection to "+90% of health plans," no year-long contracts and custom pricing.
- Commercial plans: TriZetto says they need no enrollment for claims, and that ERA enrollment "takes 15-30 days on average."
- Government plans: it says these need enrollment for claims and remits. Its claim enrollment averages 3 to 15 days, and ERA enrollment can take 5 to 30 days.
- Gap to plan for: payers outside that 90%, and ERAs while enrollment runs.
Our TriZetto clearinghouse guide covers payer coverage and ERA enrollment times.
Waystar
Waystar publishes counts on its payer list. As of November 18, 2026, it showed 4,869 active payers for professional claims, 4,634 for institutional claims, 3,211 for remits, 1,572 for claim attachments, 1,173 for eligibility and 923 for claims monitoring. The list has a filter for payers that require enrollment.
- Enrollment: Waystar's enrollment support page says it pre-populates enrollment forms, applies e-signatures to payer EDI agreements, and tracks status in a dashboard.
- Gap to plan for: the difference between claim payers and remit, eligibility or monitoring payers. For payers outside those lists, plan to get ERAs, eligibility and status another way, such as the payer's portal or phone line.
Our Waystar clearinghouse guide goes through its payer list and enrollment.
Gaps every clearinghouse shares
Some work stays outside every clearinghouse, because payers don't support it electronically. CAQH's 2025 Index put fully electronic adoption in medical at 98% for claim submission but 40% for prior authorization and 24% for attachments.
- Prior authorization mostly runs through payer portals, fax and phone. Our guide to prior authorization turnaround times covers the CMS deadlines.
- Attachments now have HIPAA standards, but CMS's attachments final rule doesn't require compliance until May 26, 2028.
- Appeals often go straight to the payer. UnitedHealthcare takes reconsiderations and appeals through its provider portal or an API.
- Medicare ERAs go to one receiver. CMS's 2017 guide to reading an institutional remittance advice says MACs "will allow only one receiver of an ERA per National Provider Identifier (NPI)." Our guide to ERA enrollment timelines covers why ERAs stop arriving.
Dental adds its own gaps. Our guide to dental clearinghouses covers them.
Should you run a second clearinghouse?
A second clearinghouse can reach payers your main one doesn't, and it gives you somewhere to send claims during an outage. CAQH's 2025 Index says that after the Change Healthcare attack, "the industry shifted transaction traffic to other clearinghouses."
The cost is a second set of enrollments. Claims may move quickly, depending on each payer's enrollment rules. ERAs usually have to be re-enrolled payer by payer. Medicare sends them to one receiver per NPI, so once a MAC moves them, the old clearinghouse stops getting them. Check your contract for exclusivity before you need to switch. Keep a list of which payers you can reach through their portals if both connections fail.
Most billing companies still end up with work that no clearinghouse carries: portal lookups, attachments, appeals and calls. Teams handle that with staff assigned by payer, payer APIs where they exist, or automation of the portal work. Our guide on mapping payer-facing work shows how to size it.
Frequently asked questions
Which clearinghouse is best for a billing company?
It depends on your payer mix. Pull your top payers by volume and check each clearinghouse's list for claims, ERAs, eligibility and claim status for those payers. Start with the one that covers the most volume with the least enrollment work.
Are there free medical billing clearinghouses?
Some offer free entry tiers. Availity Essentials is free for its sponsoring payers, and Office Ally's Service Center starts free, but both list transactions or payers that cost extra. Check fees for eligibility, attachments, paper claims and non-participating payers.
Which clearinghouses publish their payer lists?
Availity, Claim.MD, Experian Health, Office Ally and Waystar all point to payer lists from their public sites. Look for flags by transaction and for enrollment, not just payer names.
How long does it take to switch clearinghouses?
Claims to payers that don't require enrollment can move quickly. TriZetto, for example, says commercial claims can go through it immediately. ERA enrollment takes longer: TriZetto's own average is 15 to 30 days for commercial plans. Keep the old clearinghouse active until ERAs arrive at the new one.
Does a clearinghouse handle prior authorizations?
Some clearinghouses, such as Optum, list the X12 278, but payer support varies. CAQH put fully electronic prior authorization at 40% in medical, so most requests still go through payer portals, fax or phone.
Covering the payers your clearinghouse can't reach?
Champ automates payer portal work, like eligibility checks and authorizations, and can take on the document and phone work around it too. We set it up and run it, so your team sees only the finished results. If the gaps in your clearinghouse keep staff on payer portals, learn more here.
This post is general information, not legal, compliance or billing advice. Payer lists, prices and enrollment rules vary by clearinghouse and payer and change often, so confirm with each clearinghouse and your payers before acting. Champ is not affiliated with or endorsed by Availity, Claim.MD, Experian Health, Office Ally, Optum, Change Healthcare, TriZetto Provider Solutions, Cognizant, Waystar, CMS, CAQH or UnitedHealthcare.
Continue reading
See all
How to Evaluate AI Voice Agents for Payer Calls: Questions for Billing Companies
What to ask before buying an AI voice agent for payer calls: which payers will take the call, what it resolves, who finishes the hard ones, and how the BAA chain works.

The Best AI Voice Agents for Payer Calls in Healthcare RCM
A billing-company view of the AI voice agents that call insurance payers: what each one does, who it fits, and what to check before you sign.

Dental Clearinghouses: What Eligibility and Claims Still Need a Portal For
Dental clearinghouses handle most claims and eligibility checks, but claim status, remittances and attachments are still mostly not fully electronic in dental. Here is what the 271 leaves out and what dental billers still check in payer portals.